Changing Your Preferred Team in MLB The Show 26: Step-by-Step

Step 1: Open Settings

Start from the main dashboard of MLB The Show 26. Look for the gear icon in the upper corner of the screen—that’s your gateway to all customization options. Click on it to access the Settings menu.

Step 2: Access User Settings

Once inside Settings, navigate to User Settings. This section controls everything from your profile look to gameplay defaults, so it’s where all team preferences now live.

Step 3: Open the Preset Menu

MLB The Show 26 streamlined its interface compared to previous editions. Gone is the old "three dots" menu; in its place is a preset settings panel. Access it by pressing the Square button on PlayStation, X button on Xbox, or Y button on Nintendo Switch. This panel allows you to quickly adjust a variety of profile and gameplay presets.

Step 4: Set Your Favorite Team

Scroll to the bottom of the preset menu. You’ll see the option Set Favorite Team. Select it, then choose the franchise you want to designate as your new favorite. Once saved, your profile’s quick-play defaults and aesthetics will reflect your updated choice.

Adjusting Team Affiliation in Gameplay Modes

If your goal is not just a profile switch but to actually play under a new team in different modes, there are a few additional steps:

Road to the Show (RTTS): You can request a trade during your minor league contract periods when your agent contacts you. Alternatively, after completing six full MLB seasons, you enter standard free agency, allowing you to join a team of your choice.
Franchise Mode: To relocate your franchise to a new city, go to the Franchise Main Menu at the end of a season, click Rebrand Team, select a city, and customize your new uniform colors. This is perfect for players who want to manage their team from a fresh start.

Changing your favorite team in MLB The Show 26 is quick, but knowing the right menu paths and button prompts makes it even smoother. Whether you’re updating your profile or aiming for a full in-game team switch, these steps will help you get there without the guesswork.